US Retail Sales Show Fragile September Gain as Consumers Lose Momentum

US retail sales in September offered a mixed picture of consumer strength, with headline spending edging higher while underlying details pointed to a loss of momentum. After several months of solid gains, shoppers appeared to slow their pace, squeezed by rising prices and a softening job market.

The latest figures, released by the Commerce Department after a delay tied to the government shutdown, underscore how uneven the spending backdrop has become. While US retail sales still moved up overall, many households — particularly those with lower incomes — are showing growing strain, even as wealthier consumers continue to benefit from a strong stock market.

With the Federal Reserve divided over the next interest-rate move and the holiday season approaching, the September data will feed directly into debates over how resilient the consumer really is — and how long that resilience can last.

US Retail Sales in September: Modest Gain After Strong August

US retail sales rose 0.2% in September from the prior month, a clear step down from August’s 0.6% advance. The data are not adjusted for inflation, meaning part of that gain reflects higher prices rather than stronger volumes.

Excluding autos and gasoline — two volatile categories that can swing month-to-month — US retail sales increased just 0.1%. That undershoot consensus expectations and signals that core spending lost traction as the third quarter came to a close.

Economists often focus on so-called “control group” sales, which exclude food services, auto dealers, building materials stores and gasoline stations. This measure feeds directly into the government’s calculation of goods spending in gross domestic product. In September, control-group sales slipped 0.1%, the first decline in five months and a notable reversal from earlier strength.

By the government’s breakdown, 8 of the 13 major retail categories posted increases in the month. But the modest 0.2% headline rise in US retail sales, compared with stronger gains earlier in the quarter, reinforces the sense that consumers are becoming more cautious after an extended period of robust outlays.

Where Americans Spent — and Where They Cut Back

Beneath the surface, the composition of US retail sales in September showed clear shifts in how and where Americans are spending.

The categories that saw gains included:

• Gasoline stations, where higher spending likely reflects a combination of fuel prices and ongoing travel needs.
• Health and personal care stores, suggesting continued demand for day‑to‑day essentials.
• Miscellaneous retailers, a broad group that can capture a mix of smaller specialty and discount outlets.

At the same time, several key discretionary segments weakened:

• Motor vehicle and parts dealers saw sales fall, the first decline in four months. After a solid run for auto spending, that pullback hints at growing consumer fatigue with big-ticket purchases.
• Electronics and appliance stores registered lower sales, pointing to some hesitation around non‑essential upgrades.
• Clothing and accessories retailers also reported weaker activity, indicating that consumers may be trimming apparel purchases.
• Sporting goods, hobby and related stores experienced a decline as well, often a sign that households are cutting back on leisure or “nice-to-have” items.

Taken together, the breakdown suggests that US retail sales growth is increasingly being driven by necessities and specific pockets of demand, while more discretionary categories feel the impact of household budget pressure.

Income Divide Shapes US Retail Sales Outlook

The September report underscored a widening divide in US retail sales trends between higher‑income and lower‑income consumers.

Overall spending has been supported by wealthier shoppers, who have benefited from gains in the stock market and still have room in their budgets to maintain or even increase purchases. That support has helped keep headline US retail sales in positive territory, even as some segments of the population pull back.

By contrast, lower‑income households are showing clearer signs of strain. Rising prices continue to erode purchasing power, and a softening job market is adding another layer of uncertainty for many workers. As a result, more shoppers are becoming cautious, trading down, or delaying purchases.

This pressure is visible in consumer sentiment, which has slipped close to record lows. While the September retail figures do not capture sentiment directly, the combination of slower sales growth and weakness in discretionary categories is consistent with a more defensive mindset among a significant slice of the population.

Fed Debate Intensifies as Consumers Slow

The cooling in US retail sales comes at a critical moment for Federal Reserve officials, who are openly divided on whether to lower interest rates again at their upcoming meeting.

The income split in consumer behavior has been a major concern inside the central bank. Policymakers must balance signs of resilience among higher‑income households with evidence that lower‑income Americans are feeling the squeeze from both inflation and borrowing costs.

The September numbers add complexity to that discussion. On one hand, US retail sales are still positive, and eight out of 13 categories showed gains, suggesting demand has not collapsed. On the other hand, the slowdown in the control group and weakness in discretionary sectors highlight emerging fragility.

Traders in financial markets currently see a December rate cut as more likely than not, a view that could be reinforced if incoming data continue to show softer spending and sentiment. Still, the Fed’s split underscores how finely balanced the outlook has become — and how much weight officials are placing on the consumer’s ability to carry the expansion.

Retailers See Cautious Shoppers and Bigger Bargain Hunting

Front‑line retailers are already feeling the shift captured in the latest US retail sales figures. Executives at major chains have been flagging changes in customer behavior tied to affordability concerns.

• Walmart Inc. and TJX Cos., the parent of TJ Maxx and Marshalls, have both highlighted growing demand for bargains as shoppers hunt for value. This aligns with the data showing pressure on discretionary categories and relative strength at value‑oriented and miscellaneous retailers.
• Home Depot Inc. has warned that many consumers are holding off on big-ticket home purchases, a message that mirrors the decline in auto sales and softness in other high‑value categories.

These signals suggest that even as US retail sales grow in aggregate, the mix is shifting toward lower‑priced items and away from large commitments. Retailers that can lean into discounting, off‑price strategies, or essential categories may fare better than those relying heavily on premium or discretionary goods.

Holiday Spending Plans Under the Shadow of Higher Prices

With the holiday season approaching, the September report on US retail sales is an important piece of context for forecasts of year‑end demand.

According to credit reporting firm TransUnion, more than half of Americans say they expect to spend at least as much as they did last year this holiday season. On the surface, that might sound like a positive for retailers. But a closer look suggests that a sizable part of the planned “same” spending likely reflects higher prices rather than more goods in shopping carts.

Tariffs are one reason for that dynamic. As duties raise costs on certain imported products, some companies have less room to offer aggressive discounts, including on traditional events like Black Friday. That can leave shoppers paying more for similar items, even if the number of gifts or purchases does not increase.

The combination of modest US retail sales growth, a more deal‑focused consumer and limits on retailers’ ability to discount heavily sets up a holiday season where value messaging and careful inventory management could be critical.

Control-Group Sales and the Growth Picture

Beyond its headline number, the September retail report carries implications for the broader economic picture through the “control group” category.

Control-group sales — which strip out food services, auto dealers, building materials stores and gasoline stations — feed directly into the government’s calculation of goods spending in gross domestic product. In September, this measure fell 0.1%, breaking a five‑month streak of increases.

That decline suggests that, even as the overall value of US retail sales inched higher, the components most closely tied to underlying goods demand weakened. Coming at the end of an otherwise solid third quarter, the downturn in control-group spending raises questions about how much momentum will carry into the next period.

If control-group sales remain soft in subsequent months, it would reinforce the view that the consumer engine is downshifting—a development with clear implications for corporate earnings and monetary policy debates.

Conclusion: A Turning Point or a Pause for US Retail Sales?

The modest 0.2% rise in US retail sales in September captures a moment of transition for the American consumer. After a robust stretch of spending, households are becoming more selective, with wealthier shoppers keeping headline numbers afloat while lower‑income consumers struggle with higher prices and a less certain labor backdrop.

Retailers are already adapting, emphasizing value and warning of slower demand for big-ticket items. Fed officials and traders are watching closely, weighing whether this slowdown warrants another interest‑rate cut as soon as December.

Whether September marks a brief pause or the start of a more sustained cooling trend will depend on how jobs, inflation and confidence evolve in the months ahead. For now, the message from the data is clear: the era of easy, broad‑based gains in US retail sales has given way to a more fragile, uneven phase of consumer spending.

FAQ’s